2011 Roster Evaluations: Running Backs

Packers RB Brandon SaineIn a year where Aaron Rodgers’ arm fueled most of the offensive production, the Green Bay backfield was left in the shadows. James Starks picked up where he left off in the prior postseason, leaving many to believe he would become the feature back by December. Instead, a late-season resurgence by Ryan Grant kept the backfield split through the final match in January.

Kudos to Mike McCarthy for calling plays around each of his backs’ strengths rather than inserting any back into running plays. Grant, a known liability inside the tackles, used his speed to turn standard sweeps into sizable gains. Starks resumed his role as the “slasher”, picking up the dirty yards inside. John Kuhn saw increased goal line work and remained a fan favorite, picking up a pro bowl nomination in the process.

The Packers didn’t get much of a look at rookie Alex Green in 2011 after the Hawaii product landed on Injured Reserve in November. However, Green Bay got great use of undrafted free agent Brandon Saine in the second half of the season. Saine showed his value as a third down back, and in particular, a screen threat. With Saine now a capable contributor to the running game, the likely loss of Grant in free agency becomes more affordable.

Despite a respectable year out of the Packer backfield, fans were left with a bad taste in their mouths as the season came to a close. The normally reliable Grant and Kuhn both coughed up the football against the Giants, after fumbling a combined 1 time throughout the regular season. While the fumbles weren’t necessarily game changers, they played a role in preventing the Packers from getting back in the game. To go along with the fumbles, pass protection from running backs in the playoff loss was less than ideal.

Overall, Green Bay running backs benefitted from the spotlight shifting even further away from the ground game than normal. However, we can’t discredit what the unit put on display when it came time to produce. Starks and Grant found a way to co-exist in a backfield that didn’t receive many goal line carries or glory. Further, the backfield got the job done without much depth, which casts a sunny outlook for 2012.

Running Backs Grade: A-

About Mike Davidsen

Mike Davidsen grew up in the north suburbs of Chicago and graduated from Indiana University with a degree in Finance. Mike has been a Packers season ticket holder all of his life and just recently became a shareholder. Mike joined GPN in May 2010 and specializes in draft analysis.

3 Responses to “2011 Roster Evaluations: Running Backs”

  • J.R. Augustine
    Twitter: GPN_JR

    I was really impressed with how Brandon Saine looked this past season. I was a little disappointed with Starks. He showed a lot of good stuff (as he did in the Super Bowl run), but he was just too inconsistent.

    I completely agree with your comment about pass blocking too.

  • John Zoul:

    Ryan Grant is toast…Alex Green…hope he’s ready for a bigger role in the offense and not just on special teams…B. saine looks like a “comer.”

    • Mike Davidsen:

      Thing is, Grant hasn’t drawn much attention on the open market. Could end up bringing back Grant in similar fashion to Jones last August.

Leave a Reply

GPN Insiders

Get the inside scoop on what's new at GreenBay Packer Nation and get exclusive opportunities such as drawings and contests offered only to GPN members.

Larry Garry

Click Me or You'll Be Sad!

NFL Humor